| 2019 through Current | Gordon Edgar |
| 1994 through 2018 | Steven M. Clem |
| 1979 through 1994 | Judith L. McCauley |
| 1975 through 1979 | Mike Tabler, Appointed and then Elected |
| 1970 through 1975 | Fred Van Sickle, Resigned, Appointed Judge |
| 1950 through 1970 | Robert A. Hensel |
| 1942 through 1950 | Ned W Kimball |
| 1934 through 1942 | O. R. Hopewell |
| 1926 through 1934 | Frank B. Malloy |
| 1923 through 1926 | O. R. Hopewell, Appointed |
| 1920 through 1923 | S.M. Driver, Resigned |
| 1916 through 1920 | Warren N Wilson |
| 1914 through 1916 | O. R. Hopewell |
| 1910 through 1914 | J.W. Hanna |
| 1906 through 1910 | Sam B. Hill |
| 1905 through 1906 | W.J. Canton |
| 1903 through 1905 | E.T. Trimble |
| 1901 through 1903 | W.A. Reneau, Appointed |
| 1901 through 1901 | E.K. Pendergast, Resigned |
| 1900 through 1901 | R.W. Starr |
| 1897 through 1900 | E.K. Pendergast |
| 1895 through 1897 | M.B. Malloy |
| 1892 through 1895 | George Bradley |
| 1891 through 1892 | E.K. Pendergast |
| 1890 through 1891 | J.S. Andrews, Died in Office |
| 1889 through 1890 | W. Mount |
| 1887 through 1889 | T.S. Roadman |
| 1885 through 1887 | S.C. Hyde |
| 1884 through 1885 | Arthur Hyde, Appointed |